The Voice of the Mountain Resort Industry  |  Est. 1962

Advertisement

Pro Deals Leaderboard

May 2009 Issue

A Slightly Skeptical Look at Global Warming

What is hype and what is real when it comes to global warming?

Several years ago a college in Colorado issued a report that confidently predicted the precise levels of retreat of snowlines at ski areas in the Rocky Mountains during coming years as greenhouse gases accumulate in the atmosphere. By 2081, for example, the report predicted Taos will lose 89 percent of its April 1 snowpack.

No doubt, there is value in estimating snow retreat. Climatic change is already happening, and the large majority of scientists believe that the greenhouse gases resulting from the burning of fossil fuels play a substantial or even overwhelming role. Projections like the one above suggest the magnitude of change being contemplated.

But too often, the story of climate change gets oversimplified or oversold. In some cases, predictions like the one above become branded with a certainty that just does not yet exist—and may never exist.

In fact, global warming theory is rife with gaps. Scientists believe they have the big picture right. Temperatures will rise—that is clearly understood. But whether the increases will be 2º F or 10º F in the next 100 years, no one can say for sure. Precipitation levels remain uncertain. Above all, while scientists say they understand the global energy balance well, local energy balances are more uncertain.

FACT V. PREDICTION

Among the biggest gaps in the computer models is how clouds operate. They reflect light and hence heat. But they also prevent the loss of heat. What’s the difference between a winter night with clouds and one without? The energy balance isn’t clearly understood, a big question mark given that clouds—water vapor—represent 60 percent of the greenhouse effect.

Neither do scientists understand many of the physical processes, such as those involving moisture produced by plants, which may play a role in influencing the rate of climate change. Also, how will plants react to higher levels of carbon dioxide? If plants disappear, because of more drought (as is predicted for the American Southwest), scientists say temperatures are likely to become more extreme, like the Sahara—both hotter by day and colder by night.

Computers still lack the power to fully reflect the complexity of atmospheric processes and topography, including mountains. Until recently, the Rocky Mountains and Sierra Nevada were only the slightest bumps in global circulation models. Even newer, more powerful computer models continue to deliver somewhat vague images of the future in localized areas, far fuzzier than the pinpoint-sharp images suggested by many studies.

Does any of this uncertainty suggest ski areas—and our planetary civilizations—can continue business as usual? No. But knowing the uncertainties makes at least some climate scientists a bit uneasy by the brashness of seeming supporters.

THE LIMITS OF SCIENCE

Kevin Trenberth, a native of New Zealand, heads the climate analysis section of the National Center for Atmospheric Research. He admits to squirming a bit when hearing some blanket statements from Al Gore and others. “We know enough to know there is a substantial problem, and the planet will become a very different planet in 50 years, based on our current knowledge. But the science is far from being done in terms of specifying any detail about that, especially locally and regionally,” says Trenberth, who was lead author of the scientific assessments issued in 1995, 2001 and 2007 by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

“I don’t think people have accurately reflected those uncertainties in their statements about the future,” he says, referring especially to some environmental groups. While there are compelling reasons to change our combustion of fossil fuels, he went on to say, climate change, unlike the disappearing ozone hole, is not necessarily an unmitigated disaster. “If it occurs gradually enough, some of the changes are not necessarily bad, and I don’t think that is sometimes adequately appreciated.”

There will be, Trenberth says, both winners and losers. Houston and Miami will lose because of rising sea levels. The Rocky Mountains, being high and inland, might be OK in the shorter time frame, but lose in the longer term because of increased wildland fires, longer droughts, and far shorter and warmer winters. Ski areas, in time, could become big-time losers as they’re currently operated, unless the change is slowed.

Advertisement

Climb Zip Whip Leaderboard

This is not to suggest that there is unanimity about global warming theory. There is not. The dissent cannot be simplistically attributed to brainless “deniers.” Particularly those scientists trained as meteorologists have reservations. There are others, as well, including Freeman Dyson, a highly regarded theoretical physicist and mathematician, whose skepticism on aspects of global warming theory was documented in a New York Times Magazine profile published in March.

One long-standing critic is Roger Pielke Sr., a senior research associate in the Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences at the University of Colorado-Boulder. Pielke does not dispute that the climate is changing. He does argue the relative responsibility of various causes. For decades he has maintained that mainstream climate change theory attributes too much causality to emissions of carbon dioxide, the most common greenhouse gas emitted by human activity. He believes that changes in land use resulting from the activities of people and what he describes as the spatial variations in pollution particles bear at least equal responsibility.

“Tropical deforestation clearly has an effect on both regional and global climate that is at least as important as the radiative effect of adding carbon dioxide,” Pielke told one interviewer in 2007, and he made similar comments to a Congressional committee in 2008. The role of land resource processes was underreported in the body of the 2007 IPCC report, he claims, and essentially ignored in the companion IPCC Statement for Policymakers.

Aerosols—tiny particles suspended in the atmosphere resulting from wildfires, combustion of fossil fuels, and dust storms—also have an underappreciated role, he insists.

If Pielke is correct, reduction of carbon dioxide should be just one of a host of menu options. “The current focus on using reductions in C02 emissions as the primary currency for achieving benefits to society and the environment clearly represents a very flawed approach,” he told EcoWorld.com.

Trenberth—and the majority of climate change scientists—reject many of Pielke’s assertions as overstated or downright wrong. But Trenberth readily concedes the failure of computer global climate models to reflect the enormous heterogeneity of land surfaces. “You need only look out the window to see all the different human influences, the roads and villages and towns, that are altering the landscape,” he says. “Those are not adequately dealt with in climate models, there’s no doubt about that.”

THE LITTLE PICTURE: FUZZY

Yet some factors are more important than others. Trenberth believes that the aerosol production from cities, while able to influence weather and ultimately the climate on a local and even regional scale, does not have global influence. More consequential, he says, is the inability of computer models to accurately represent mountains.

Sign in or enable JavaScript to keep reading.

Advertisement

Creative Design Billboard