The Voice of the Mountain Resort Industry  |  Est. 1962

Advertisement

Creative Designs Leaderboard

March 2012 Issue

Blue Pages :: March 2012

NSAA SUES FOREST SERVICE OVER WATER RULE
The National Ski Areas Association (NSAA) has sued the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) to challenge a new water rights clause that NSAA terms “an unconstitutional taking of property.” That clause, enacted by the USFS in November 2011, requires ski areas operating on Forest Service land to transfer ownership of many water rights to the U.S. government, including water rights that have been purchased or developed by ski areas entirely on private or non-federal land, for business operations. Three ski areas have already had the new terms written into their special use permits: Powderhorn, Colo., Alpine Meadows, Calif., and Stevens Pass, Wash.

The latest water rights clause changes a 2004 agreement reached between the Forest Service and the ski industry and conflicts with the 150-year-old system of state allocation and administration of water rights.

The Forest Service says that the change is intended to keep water resources that originate on National Forest land tied to the land, to ensure that water rights developed for ski area use remain with the ski area, should the original or current owner of those rights sell the area and attempt to use the water rights for other purposes. And the current clause retains a provision in the 2004 rule for joint ownership of water rights to divert and use water on the permitted area. Jim Pena, acting chief deputy for the Forest Service, said the clause is not yet final, and has pledged to work with permittees to ensure that the water rights of both resorts and the Forest Service are protected.

But that’s not how NSAA president Michael Berry views the changes. “We have no guarantee that they will continue to use the water for purposes of ski area business,” he said. “The government could decide to use the water and apply it to other uses or even sell it.”

Unless there’s a resolution soon, the issue could wind up before a jury this summer.

 

Sign in or enable JavaScript to keep reading.

Advertisement

Pro Deals Billboard