With all the change occurring in our industry and the world right now, change is a big topic. So big, in fact, that the trick is to figure out what part of change to focus on. Here, we’re going to zero in on what drives change in our industry, the three basic phases of change, what goes wrong during change, and finally, what we should expect from people caught up in change.
Change is, simply, a significant difference in what was before. In business, change is something to strive for. In the words of Kudray and Kleiner (who wrote “Global Trends in Managing Change”) it is “the continuous process of aligning an organization with its marketplace—and doing so more responsibly and effectively than competitors.”
Industry Triggers
There are two primary triggers of change in an organization: external and internal. To name a few:
External
• laws and regulations: tram safety, immigration reform, international worker regulations, rulings on ski-related lawsuits
• globalization of markets and business: the dollar vs. the pound, euro, and Canadian dollar
• political, environmental and social issues: the greening of the ski industry, the real estate market, election year
• ownership: mergers, consolidations and REITs, oh my!
• technology: Raise your hand if you have a Blackberry…or…what year did you start using e-mail as your preferred method of communication?
• competition: changing customer expectations, a shift in customer access, databases and storefronts
• weather: shortened seasons, January thaw, rain events, global warming
Internal
• financials: expenses and overhead vs. revenue issues, pricing thresholds, capital improvements, the stagnant skier marketplace
• technology: snowmaking and lift advancements, integration of IT systems (ticket, hospitality, financial, HR, etc.)
• people: ownership stability, leadership bandwidth, nepotism, labor pools, bench strength of the up and comers, the old guard vs. the new guard, cross pollination—leaders moving between companies
• branding: target markets, reinventing ourselves, moving toward an all-season business model
• administrative structures: layoffs, reassignments, organizational right-sizing, managing expenses and overhead while maintaining positive community relations
Really, the list is never ending. Russ Coloton of Hunter Mountain summed it up best. “There’s a definition on the board in my office, I read it, discuss it and try to live up to it every day with every staff member: ‘Lean: the process of creating precise customer value with higher quality and fewer defects, with less human effort, less space, less capital, and less time.’”
Perhaps that’s the true definition of change in the ski industry.
Change Process
Viewed simply, change is a three-part process: the Present State, the Desired State and the in-between Neutral Zone. The Present State represents current systems, processes, policies, and people involved in the organization. The Desired State is the vision, outcome or result that the change decision describes. It’s what the organization seeks to do or be.
The Neutral Zone is the period of time the organization will go through when the Present State no longer exists and the Desired State has not yet been achieved. It’s the most easily recognized state of change, largely because it’s the most uncomfortable. The Neutral Zone is also marked by something called Transition, the predominantly psychological process people must go through to adapt to and embrace the Desired State.
The hallmarks of an effective organization are efficiency, flexibility and rapid adaptation to change. A sign of these characteristics is that there is prompt and widespread acceptance of change.
Advertisement
Such businesses are rare. Many organizations get stuck in the Neutral Zone inadvertently. This is usually caused by processes and systems that are in flux and undependable, and by a polarization between individuals who want to move forward and those hanging onto the “old ways.” Being stuck in transition causes gossip, mistrust, apathy, anxiety, resistance and sometimes even sabotage.
How quickly people get through the Neutral Zone depends on a number of factors, such as the significance of the change, whether the individual chose the change, what the individual will gain or lose as a result of change, and the amount and severity of change occurring in other parts of the individual’s life. The leaders in an organization also play a significant role in easing transition for staff.
Managing Change
Several key actions can inspire trust, which is at the heart of managing change.
1. Increase structure and reduce ambiguity. Most people strive toward control or influence over their environment. Change, particularly change one didn’t initiate or choose, causes discomfort. The resistant feelings people have about change are basically about lack of control. So, validate the notion that the change is happening or going to happen openly with people, and keep on with the processes and systems that worked for you in the Present State. People sometimes assume that if change is coming, that they should halt all activities. Stick with some elements of the old structure to reduce ambiguity and increase the comfort level.
2. Communicate, Communicate, Communicate! Maintain—in fact, increase—your regular staff meetings, functions, and other communication vehicles so folks can see that life and business continue during change.
Inform everyone, at every level, regularly. Not knowing what will happen next just makes people uncomfortable. Feed the grapevine by communicating regularly and formally, even when there isn’t much to communicate. In a void of information people will make up their own reality.
3. Make room for participation. Give employees a role to play in reaching your Desired State. Wherever possible, solicit input on how to create the steps and outcomes you want. Use focus groups, surveys, task forces or one-on-one interviews to find out what your staff thinks the desired state should look like. Participation creates informed staff, and that lowers potential resistance.
4. Measure and Celebrate. Every change has many steps, phases, stages and setbacks. It’s much easier for folks to recognize failures and setbacks than to see the new order. The solution? Set and publicize meaningful but attainable short-term goals to ensure success and movement through the process. Shamelessly advertise your milestones and success. If you’re not talking about them, nobody is!
5. Start with the most senior level team in the organization. Regularly and candidly discuss the real milestones and setbacks of the change initiative. Seek ownership, clarity, and consensus within this team. The overall organization is only as functional as its most senior team. If they are dysfunctional in the process of change, the organization will clearly mirror it.
Pitfalls of Change
The greatest pitfall of change management is failing to complete the change. New strategies aren’t well implemented, expected synergies are never fully achieved, and stabilization becomes the goal. Suspicion, confusion, cynicism, and self preservation spread and can take years to overcome.
You need allies to make change succeed, and they are easy enough to find. At the start of any change the people in your organization generally separate into three different groups; Initiators, Defenders and the Majority. Guess who your friends are.
The Initiators represent about 16 percent of your organization and usually include senior leaders/owners that have done the research, run the numbers, analyzed the marketplace and made the decision to change.
The Defenders also represent 16 percent of the organization, albeit a frequently vocal percentage. Defenders actively defend the status quo. They have yet to see and understand the rationale for change; if they aren’t soon convinced, they often become resistant. But they also represent an opportunity. If you can convert this vocal minority—which often includes crusty, highly skilled technicians with lots of tenure with the organization—to Initiators, how much faster and easier your change management process will be!
The final and largest segment of the organization in change is the Majority; 68 percent of folks will settle comfortably here. Comfort is just what the Majority seeks; not willing to make a choice for or against change, they don’t contribute a whole lot until pressed. This adds to the likelihood that the organization will experience a longer and more complicated Neutral Zone.