The Voice of the Mountain Resort Industry  |  Est. 1962

Advertisement

Run Smarter Banner

July 2013 Issue

Blue Pages :: July 2013

VAIL GOES ALL IN AT CANYONS… GOING WILD AT LAKE LOUISE… FOREST SERVICE WINDFALL IN ASPEN… SNOW SUMMIT EXPLORES POSSIBLE SALE… CANADIEN CONS… SHORTSWINGS

VAIL GOES ALL IN AT CANYONS
In late May, Vail Resorts (VR) and Talisker shook the resort world by announcing that VR had leased Talisker-owned Canyons for $25 million a year (minimum, with escalator clauses) for 50 years, with the option to renew the lease six times.

The deal itself was not a complete surprise; Vail had sought Canyons for years. VR tried to purchase the area in 2007, when Talisker won a bidding war for the resort. Vail challenged its loss in court before abandoning the effort in 2009. Under the new lease, VR has now assumed all of the resort operations while Talisker has retained its development rights for four million square feet of real estate at the resort.

There are, though, two shockers in this deal: first, the price; and second, the inclusion of the land that Park City leases (or has in the past leased) from Talisker.

Let’s talk price first. On the surface, this looks like a terrible deal for Vail. The lease cost is equal to about $60 for every resort visit Canyons recorded last season (roughly 450,000). For 2013-14, VR expects Canyons to earn $15 million or so in earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA)—and before it makes its annual lease payment of $25 million. Vail projects it will continue to increase Canyons’ annual visits at a fast pace, as Talisker has, and achieve $25 million in EBITDA by 2017.

Still, that’s just break-even, and that is based on some optimistic assumptions about increasing sales of Epic Passes and continued visitor growth. So what else is there?

For one thing, greater penetration into the southern California and Utah markets, which have been among VR’s weakest. If Canyons is the entry point for many thousands of new Epic Pass sales, and that leads to increased business for other VR resorts, then this deal could bring in calculable revenues. In addition, as Talisker develops its four million square feet of real estate at Canyons, the resulting visits could swell the VR coffers, too.

Then there’s all that disputed land under Park City Mountain Resort (PCMR). Most of PCMR’s downhill terrain is on land that was originally leased from United Park City Mines (UPCM). But Talisker bought UPCM a decade ago, and when the lease was up for renewal in 2011—well, that’s where it gets interesting. The courts will determine if the lease was renewed. PCMR claims it took the necessary steps to renew; Talisker says no.

Advertisement

Commerce A - Billboard

And now, as part of its lease, VR has inherited Talisker’s stake in this dispute. To quote from the official press release, because it’s too difficult to parse this: “The transaction also incorporates the potential for the lease, without additional consideration, to include the land under the ski terrain of Park City Mountain Resort that is adjacent to Canyons and is currently owned by Talisker and is subject to pending litigation.” If Park City’s lease wasn’t renewed, what happens then?

That’s the $25,000,000 question. In a conference call with stock analysts in late May, VR CEO Rob Katz said that the potential value of the UPCM land was a key part of the deal. He was vague and evasive (even by the standards of analyst calls) as to what that value might be, except to hint that it might be significant enough to make an otherwise crazy-looking deal seem really smart. Even if it did carry risk of returning next to nothing.

Katz was a bit more straightforward in the official press release, where he said, “We look forward to the litigation being resolved and hope that Vail Resorts can play a constructive role in helping to arrive at a solution that offers the best outcome for guests of both resorts.” Will VR be able to strike a deal with PCMR, where Talisker couldn’t?

Sign in or enable JavaScript to keep reading.

Advertisement

Commerce A - Billboard