I swear I have to be the only person in the industry who has actually read this report page by page. Well, two of us. I made my editor, Rick Kahl, read it, too. It was my revenge for letting him talk me into doing this for a second straight year. As usual, the reward for slogging through it is a lot of good information, some questions and, I hope, some insights into the industry.
Good News and Bad
Though it doesn’t quite come right out and say it, the report validates the success of the strategy that we’ve been pursuing as an industry for maybe 10 years. All the money we’ve spent on lifts, lodges and terrain parks—not to mention stuff like putting up signs to the rest rooms and simplifying the rental and lesson process—is paying off. We’ve improved our competitive positioning. The 105 resorts in the survey reported 55.1 million skier visits. That’s down 6.5% from the record 58.9 million in 2005-06, but we’ve had 57-plus million visits in five of the previous six years. Remember when we were struggling around 50 million?
Even with the decline in visits and a season five days shorter than in 2005-06, operating profit as a percent of revenue grew from 24.4 to 24.8 percent. The peak was 25.1 percent in 2004-05. Profit before tax grew from 12.1 to 12.3 percent. And total revenue per skier visit was up a whopping 10.3 percent to $74.94. Lift ticket revenue grew 9 percent to $34.52, and non ticket revenue rose to $40.42, an 11.4 percent increase.
Before I become positively giddy here, there’s a little perspective I want to give you. It’s important we realize what this report is and isn’t.
This is a report on the performance of 105 mostly larger areas. “Clearly,” the report states, “this report as a whole contains more large resorts and fewer small areas than the overall distribution of U.S. ski areas…”
That’s putting it mildly. The average annual skier/boarder visits for the 105 areas that participated in the survey was 307,571. As the report points out, the national average is about 124,000 visits. Areas that participated in the survey represent 32.3 million visits, or 58.6 percent of total annual visits. And the 29 largest participating resorts, averaging 680,793 visits each, account for 19.7 million visits by themselves. That’s 35.8 percent of total visits in the U.S., and 61 percent of the visits represented in the report.
More perspective: NSAA’s website says there are 485 areas in the United States (down from 720 in 1984-85). Of these, 326 are NSAA members and, according to NSAA, account for 90 percent of annual visits. Using my trusty Hewlett Packard financial calculator I conclude that 159 areas in the U.S. do not belong to NSAA, and that in the 2006-07 season, they hosted an estimated 6.12 million visits, or 38,490 each.
RRC Associates (which conducted the survey) also included in one of the appendices the 10-page survey instrument, which requires quite a bit of detailed information. Looking at it, I’m thinking that if you don’t have the systems and personnel to conveniently complete it, you are less likely to respond.
Okay, I’ll just come out and say it. For all the good information this report contains, it is simply not representative of the industry as a whole. I suspect most of us already knew that, but it helps to really understand how strong the bias towards big resorts is.
With that little piece of perspective as a foundation for the discussion, let’s move on.
The Five Year Table/Results by Size
I love the Five-Year Financial Data table. I’d love it even more if the same data could be broken down by resort size. Maybe next year.
The chart shows that since the 2002-03 season, profit before tax has increased at an annual rate of 13.3 percent. And we do that how? Well, by increasing gross revenues 4.3 percent a year while operating expense grows by only 3.9 percent a year. But that leaves operating profit (EBITDA) only increasing by 5.6 percent a year. It takes a small annual increase in depreciation (0.6 percent), a 3 percent annual decline in operating lease payments, and interest expense going up only 2.4 percent annually to get us to a 13.3 percent increase in pretax profit.
“It is clear,” according to the report, “that the industry as a whole has shown substantial improvement during the past five years.”
By now you know I don’t think this performance represents the industry. And while we’re at it, what does “substantial” mean? Our pretax profits were up 66.4 percent over these five years. If you’d put your money in a NASDAQ index fund on January 1, 2003 and left it there until December 31, 2007, you’d be up 80 percent with a lot less risk. So it may or not be substantial, but it’s not all that impressive from a strictly financial point of view.
One more thing about the five-year table before we move on: of the 66.4 percent five-year increase in pretax profits, 38.3 percent occurred between the 2003-04 and 2004-05 seasons.
Last year, as one or two of you may recall, we observed that the success of the large resorts overshadowed and obfuscated the financial performance of the other size categories. From the discussion above, we know that’s still true, but how big are the differences this year?
Advertisement
Huge. To see for yourself, check out the table I’ve created below.
I guess I’m supposed to analyze this and say something sage about it. But you can read as well as I can. The good news is largely clustered in the Super Size Me category. We’re getting more visitors, and they are giving us more money each time they come, but the bottom line benefits are accruing almost exclusively to the largest resorts. Unless, of course, the picture is different for the 78 percent of resorts in the country who don’t participate in the survey.
I wonder what the profit after tax numbers look like? They are lower than the pretax, of course. Boy, returns like this really make you wonder why some of these resorts are in business. But as we’ve seen above, the answer seems to be that a lot fewer are. Perhaps they are making it up in real estate, which isn’t tracked in this report.
Before moving on to the balance sheet ratios, I want to focus your attention on a table in the appendix called Average Ski Area Characteristics By Profitability. It divides all the participating areas into top half profit, bottom half profit, and loss. It shows that 34 of the resorts in the survey lost money, up from 32 last year.
The table doesn’t include financial data. But it does have some interesting information on resort sizes and visits. To nobody’s surprise, the resorts in the top half of profits are the largest areas in terms of average acres, visits, capacity and employees. The bottom half profit areas are smaller. For example, the top half has average skiable/boardable acres of 1,553, and visits of almost 530,000. The bottom half profit areas have 420 acres, and average visits of 155,000.
But the really interesting thing is that the 34 areas with losses are in between those in the top and bottom halves of profit in terms of acres, visits, and employees. They have, for example, 904 acres and average visits of 229,000. Some wise person once said that it’s bad, in any industry, to be “stuck in the middle.” Feels like we’ve got a bunch of resorts with physical plants more like large resorts, but revenue opportunities closer to that of the smaller ones. That’s a bad place to be. (For more discussion of this, check out RRC’s sessions at the winter trade fairs; the presentations are available on the NSAA website.—Ed.)
You know what I’d really like to see? Some numbers on maybe a dozen of those small resorts that aren’t members of NSAA and average something like 35,000 visitors each. I wonder if we wouldn’t find them doing just fine.
I don’t usually spend any time focused on the results by region, but as long as I’ve included it in the subtitle, I guess I should point out that resorts in the Rockies had a pretax profit (20.5 percent) that blew all the other regions away. The Midwest, at 5.6 percent, was the next largest.
Balance Sheet and Cash Flow
I have no idea what to make of the net working capital and current ratio numbers (all numbers in thousands, losses in parentheses). Net Working Capital grew from $235 to $2,157 for all resorts. For small resorts, it declined from $376 to ($36). For mediums, it grew from $324 to $1,148, and for larges, fell from $272 to ($1,189). The Super Size Me group went from ($20) to $7,236. The current ratio numbers jumped all over the place, too, but I won’t bore you with the specifics.
Maybe some balance sheet dates changed. No doubt some deals impact this. These numbers in businesses this seasonal just aren’t worth much. RRC acknowledges this when they state, “Some of these ratios change throughout the year, and the situation as of fiscal year end might not typically be consistently the case throughout the operating cycle of the year.”
Some of the other ratios based on the balance sheet (see Table 2, below) give us a better picture of what’s going on, and are consistent with the trends we saw in Table I.