The Voice of the Mountain Resort Industry  |  Est. 1962

Advertisement

Mountains Don’t Move Themselves

July 2010 Issue

Real Estate Gets Real

The current state of the real estate market is a wake-up call for resorts.

Will resort real estate ever recover from The Great Recession? If it does, who will buy, and what will they be looking for?

Speculators, who helped spur double-digit appreciation at resorts for nearly two decades, are largely gone from the vacation property market. But there is plenty of speculation about what comes next.

For the moment, at least, we’ve seen the end of the frantic pre-sale events, the fast-track building projects, and the euphoria of using real estate as a cash cow to bankroll chairlifts, terrain expansions and day lodges. The party is over, but the hangover remains. And it’s more painful than anything the industry has experienced in decades.

“We’ve entered a new reality,” says James Chung, president of Reach Advisors, a New York-based strategy and research firm. “In 2006, we were being told that ski resort real estate could never drop in price and that demand would always outstrip supply. The common line was, ‘They don’t make mountains anymore.’ But we were in a bubble, and supply wasn’t a function of demand as much as capital availability. Everyone said [ski resort] real estate was a brilliant investment, but in fact it never was an investment. It’s actually the worst class of real estate, because it doesn’t appreciate on an inflation-adjusted basis.”

Granted, some people made a quick profit by flipping properties, but Chung believes that had more to do with timing and luck in an overheated market.

He ticks off the current downsides: Real estate prices in many locations have plummeted 40 percent or more. There is a huge inventory of properties that will take years to work through, plus a shadow inventory that is being withheld from the market. In addition, he calculates another 25,000 units planned for the next five years, many of which won’t get built.

Timeshares and fractionals-once hailed as the antidote to high prices-are losing steam because “their cost exceeds their value,” Chung says. That’s due in part to expensive annual maintenance fees and amenities that most people don’t need or want. “These were not consumer-driven; they were developer-driven,” says Chung. “The economic challenge with this model is that it only works when there is a solid middle class with excess cash, and we don’t see that happening in the foreseeable future.”

Advertisement

Prinoth Snow Measurement - Billboard

Another big trend, says Chung, is that Baby Boomers, the backbone of the vacation market for nearly two decades, seem to be tapped out. “This generation is now beyond its peak years of real estate purchasing,” he says.

Chung believes that whatever model evolves next will be based on actual consumer demand. “Developers got fat and happy from behaviors that don’t exist anymore. They’re going to have to rethink the future and realize that they’re not going to see the profit margins of the past,” he says.

Sign in or enable JavaScript to keep reading.

Advertisement

Creative Design Billboard