The Voice of the Mountain Resort Industry  |  Est. 1962

Advertisement

Mountains Don’t Move Themselves

Fall 1977 Issue

In Court

I have noticed that in a number of legal suits filed against ski areas the complainants have indicated their belief that the area failed to warn them of some impending "danger" and, as a result, they injured themselves.

Warnings may be implicit or implied, and a practicing attorney is in a better position to advise you in total than am I. However, as a much-used “expert” in skiing accident litigation, I can at least give you some benefit of my experience in such actions that involve “failure to warn.”

There was a case in the midwest involving a trail closing, and yet the preponderance of evidence placed before the jury could support the plaintiff’s contention that the trail was not closed. He had several witnesses testify that the trail was not marked “Closed” and therefore the plaintiff was not negligent himself in the use of it. The area, of course, testified that the trail was closed to the public, and supported this claim with testimony from several Ski Patrollers. The problem was that there were more “witnesses” who claimed “open” than those who claimed “closed.” The jury, being made up of non-skiers, could not do more than weigh the evidence they heard. They couldn’t be expected to know that merely because the lift at the trail was not operating and that there was fresh powder eight inches deep, untouched, on a Saturday afternoon when the area was crowded, that there was an excellent chance that the trail was indeed closed. The witnesses for the plaintiff said they saw no warning that the trail was closed.

Advertisement

Commerce A - Sidebar

Advertisement

Pro Deals Billboard